The great Italian director, Paolo Sorrentino, works in images and doesn't seem to have mastered the craft of narrative. This is a minor deficiency -- Fellini was one of world's most famous and finest directors and, at least after La Strada, more or less abandoned coherent narrative. Sorrentino is a disciple of Fellini and, similarly, uninterested in devising a plot for his films -- instead, he orchestrates moods using lavish, opulent cinematography, operatic characters, and surreal, baffling imagery. Parthenope (2023) is one of his most characteristic works -- like its leading lady, the film's sheer beauty has been held against it. Surly critics note the production involvement of Saint Laurent in the movie's credits and accuse the picture of being as empty and glamorous as a perfume ad. The movie is excellent, but, as with late Fellini, often a matter of taste and, certainly, a test of the viewer's "negative capability", that is, willingness to abide with mystery and enigma.
Parthenope is a beautiful young woman. The film bearing her name depicts her life from birth through old age -- the movie ends with her retirement from the Department of Anthropology at the University of Trento where she has become a beloved and influential professor. She is born in the water of a lagoon, a blue basin near the Palazzo where her wealthy family lives. Her godfather, the Commandante, names her Parthenope for the sea-nymph who sought to seduce Odysseus with her voice, failed, and, then, drowned herself in the sea. Her body washed up at the site of Naples and she is regarded as the mythic patron to the city. (There are images in renaissance emblem books of water from Parthenope's breasts quenching the furious fires of Vesuvius). Parthenope's supernatural beauty entrances her brother Raimondo as well as the housekeeper's handsome son. Parthenope, like the young Jesus in the Temple, amazes the doctors at the university with her sagacity and self-assurance. She adulates Marotto, an aging professor of anthropology and expresses a wish to become a scholar herself. With her brother, Raimondo, and the maid's son, she goes to the island of Capri where she meets, by amazing coincidence (Sorrentino's plotting is very perfunctory) John Cheever, played by Gary Oldman. (Parthenope loves Cheever's writing.) When she asks Cheever to walk with her, the elderly depressed man says that the won't because he "doesn't want to rob her of a second of her youth." An oligarch whose helicopter hovers over the beach where she bathes, courts her unsuccessfully -- when she rejects him, he bluntly tells her that she is very stupid. Ultimately, Parthenope has sex with the maid's gorgeous son; her brother, Raimondo, is heart-broken and his incestuous desire causes him to commit suicide. During his funeral in Naples, his hearse is met by a hideous-looking VW bus spewing fumes from arthropoid spider-leg nozzles (the bus looks like a centipede) -- this is disinfectant against cholera which has come to Naples. Parthenope, who excels in her studies in anthropology, drops out of school briefly because a talent agent has told her she could be an actress (The talent agent, always swathed in veils or steam in her steambath, tries to seduce Parthenope, also unsuccessfully.) Parthenope is told to visit a woman (stage-)named Greta Cool. This is a "diva", a famous actress on the order of Sophia Loren. At a celebration, Cool denounces Naples, which is her home town, as being corrupt, shabby, venal, and wretched. This leads to Cool's confrontation with a City Father, a sort of gnome or ogre, whom she kicks repeatedly in the shins and, then, tries to bite off his ear. He knocks off her red wig revealing that Greta Cool suffers from alopecia. Discussion with Greta Cool leads Parthenope to renounce her ambitions to be an actress. She tours Naples' teeming slums with a mafia boss who leads her through the mean streets to a pool hall where a pale young man and young woman are forced to copulate in public, some sort of weird ritual featuring the "fusion" of two houses of criminals in the Gomorrha ghetto. Parthenope is pregnant with the mob boss's child but gets an abortion. She returns to the long-suffering Professor Marotto to complete the doctoral dissertation -- Marotto tells her to write on the cultural and anthropological aspects of the miracle of San Gennaro. Parthenope goes to the Cathedral to watch the miracle, which involves the liquefaction on Gennaro's feast-day of a clot of Christ's blood. The miracle fails but a woman in the congregation spills her menstrual blood on the cathedral floor -- the coming of her period is another sort of miracle. (The sequence is very redolent of the miraculous apparition of the virgin that causes a riot in a rainstorm in La Dolce Vita.) Parthenope visits the Bishop of Naples, Teserone in his luxurious apartments. He decks her naked body with jewels from the Cathedral's treasury and puts his hands on her genitals. At that moment, the camera retreats from the love scene, through the various spectacular corridors of the palace, to the San Gennaro relic where we hear a faint dripping as if the clot of blood has, at least, partially liquefied. Professor Marotto retires. He lives alone with his disabled son. Marotto's wife has left him and the old man sleeps on a cot in the room where his son is confined. Parthenope visits Marotto's home and is ushered into the room where the retarded boy is watching TV. (He's like a grotesque Italian version of Beavis or Butthead; he crows about the Tv announcer saying the word "asshole.") The boy is a vast ballon of marble-white flesh, a huge swollen mass the size of house with a tiny smirking face on the front of his globular head. Parthenope declares that the boy is "beautiful" and strokes his marmoreal flesh. In a brief epilogue, we see Parthenope, now about seventy, retiring from the anthropology department where two young women declare her influence to have been decisive in their lives. That night, Parthenope goes outside and sees a huge parade -- the enthusiastic supporters of Naples soccer team are marching in the street under fireworks. The team has won the Italian equivalent of the world series. Parthenope is excited herself and says: "Much time has passed. But I'm still here. I defend the City." (Sorrentino is an avid soccer fan; the movie he directed before this film The Hand of God is a coming-of-age picture keyed to soccer and a controversial goal by Diego Maradona in Mexico City in 1986, the so-called "hand of God" goal.)
The movie is wonderful but, also, somewhat indecipherable. It many ways it resembles Sorrentino's equally bizarre and enigmatic series made for HBO, The Young Pope (2016)and The Old Pope (2019)-- indeed, some scenes are almost identical including the horror-movie reveal of Stefano, Marotto's deformed and grotesque son. Many allusions are lost on non-Italian viewers -- for instance, the frog-like Commandante represents Achille Lauro, the Italian right wing political figure and shipping magnate. The mafia scenes are particularly difficult to interpret and there is a showy student riot complete with slow-motion molotov cocktails exploding -- I don't know what this represents. There are two leit motifs: men project onto Parthenope their own ideas and thoughts, often asking her "What are you thinking?" Everyone wants to know what is going on behind her gorgeous face. Another more academic aspect of the film is a question that keeps being posed: What is anthropology? After various inadequate responses, the question is answered: "Seeing." With that statement, Sorrentino aligns anthropology with film-making -- his movies are a form of anthropology. Of course, Sorrentino's break-out picture is called The Great Beauty and, I think, the rather picaresque narrative in Pathenope is about the destiny of beauty in our world. Celesta Dalla Porta plays Parthenope and, of course, she is a sight to behold.